All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by

The Lounge Board

Joined: 01/01/2005 Posts: 33818
Likes: 12458

25000+ Posts

Board Member 15+ Years

10000 Likes

2000 Likes

250 Likes

100 Likes

100 Likes

What's this?

I agree and I don't think he should be in the HoF.

For people who think he should be in, then typically that is their reasoning or some variation of it.

(In response to this post by CPRVHokie)

Posted: 05/24/2018 at 1:53PM

+0

PREV NEXT REPLY

Insert a Link

Enter the title of the link here:

Enter the full web address of the link here -- include the "http://" part:

Current Thread:

Since sports betting is now legal is Pete Rose In? ** -- bigbadbird 05/24/2018 1:10PM

Sports betting was legal in Vegas before now. ** -- 48zip 05/24/2018 2:44PM

But now the Sport Governing bodies are wanting a cut- that is a completely -- bigbadbird 05/24/2018 2:49PM

Point was it was slready legal. Anyone in his shoes -- 48zip 05/24/2018 5:29PM

Doesn't change the Rose debate at all. -- HWA 05/24/2018 2:41PM

Well, crap. Uhhhhh, what CPA said. ** -- HWA 05/24/2018 2:42PM

Nope. ** -- 48zip 05/24/2018 1:42PM

He should be, but nope. SCOTUS' decision is irrelevant. -- Hokie CPA 05/24/2018 1:19PM

So, why do you say he should be? -- Freddyburg Hokie 05/24/2018 1:36PM

Because it's a baseball museum -- Beerman 05/24/2018 6:09PM

Disagree. He should not be honored by inclusion, and here's why... -- Freddyburg Hokie 05/25/2018 09:14AM

He earned his way into the Hall as a player long before his managerial -- Hokie CPA 05/24/2018 1:54PM

What makes you think he only bet while he was a manager? ** -- SteveInBaltimore 05/24/2018 4:53PM

If he would not have denied it for so long and quite frankly been a bit.. -- turkeywinghokie 05/24/2018 2:53PM

That may be true, but he was informed every year that betting on baseball -- Freddyburg Hokie 05/24/2018 2:45PM

And earned his ban during his managerial time ** -- CPRVHokie 05/24/2018 1:56PM

Probably because he currently holds 6 MLB records -- VTHokie2000 05/24/2018 1:45PM

I concede that absent his betting, he would be a first-ballot HOF... -- Freddyburg Hokie 05/24/2018 2:47PM

I don't disagree that his stats qualify him for the HoF -- VTHokie2000 05/24/2018 3:51PM

Ichiro has more hits ** -- darnellm 05/24/2018 2:30PM

No. Most for a current player (21st all time) at 3090 +/- ** -- 48zip 05/24/2018 2:43PM

Some actions are irredeemable. Stays out. ** -- CPRVHokie 05/24/2018 1:51PM

I agree and I don't think he should be in the HoF. -- VTHokie2000 05/24/2018 1:53PM

No, over the principal of the matter. Plus, it could open the door -- VTHokie2000 05/24/2018 1:18PM

Who is the principal of gambling? ** -- bigbadbird 05/24/2018 1:20PM

This guy...stupid auto correct -- VTHokie2000 05/24/2018 1:22PM