Gable is 12-0...3 pins, 6 techs, 2 majors. Argument clearly is Gable has a tougher schedule. He's crushed #2 Parris and wrestled some tough ones.
Spencer 7-0..absurd with 5 pins, 2 techs. No one has even finished 7 minutes with him this year. Certainly not as many matches, and not as many tough matches but has hit 6 qualifiers.
Criteria: record slight edge gable, pins spencer, dominance equal, past credentials spencer by a lot (prior hodge, 2 for 2 natty, gable no titles), competition slight edge gable, heart equal, sportsmanship, some may disagree but spencer is class, gable has questionable sportsmanship at the very least depending on how you care about taunting. The way they run through the tournament could determine the winner. I got Spencer but Gable has a shot.